Damn If You Do, Damn If You Don’t: Permission to Trust Your Own Relationship Decision

This content is shared for storytelling, educational, and entertainment purposes only and is not a substitute for professional counseling or therapy.

---

There are a lot of relationship gurus online right now. A lot. To the point where it can honestly get a little overwhelming trying to figure out whose voice to trust with something as personal as your own relationship. I talk about relationships online too. I primarily focus on infidelity and what it actually takes to survive a long term relationship through trauma. But I do not identify as a therapist, and I never will pretend to be one. I am a storyteller. I share things from my own perspective and my own lived experience, and that is exactly what this post is.

I always encourage my readers and my listeners to keep an open mind and make their own judgment call. You are allowed to enjoy the information I put out here and still land somewhere different than I did. You do not have to see things from my perspective. You are allowed to twirl it into your own. What I share is meant to be a starting point for your own thinking, not a verdict on how your life should go.

---

The Clip That Reminded Me Why I Built This Community

Not too long ago I was scrolling Instagram and came across a clip of a young woman talking about infidelity. To sum it up, she said that when it comes to cheating, that is not a problem within the relationship, that is her immediate ticket to walk away. Full stop, no discussion, no nuance.

And listen, I understand the sentiment behind it. But it scared me a little, because it is exactly the kind of messaging that makes women feel like there is only one acceptable response to betrayal. This is the reason I built this platform in the first place. Because it is damn if you do, damn if you don’t. If I make the decision that works for me, that I can handle, that I want to forgive and work through, I get called stupid, ignorant, or like I do not believe in my own worth. But if I walk away, suddenly I am praised. Oh, you made such a great decision, Sherley. Good for you.

And it makes me ask, is it really that simple? Neither decision is inherently right or wrong. This is the world we live in, where a lot of people do not actually know how to listen and give sound, thoughtful advice. Instead we want to tell people what to do with their relationship. That is not what this community is here for. I share my perspective and my story, and then it is your decision how you want to apply that to your own life. That is not a decision I can make for you, and it was never meant to be.

---

---

Therapy Was Never Supposed to Hand You the Answers

I used to think going to therapy meant a therapist was going to sit me down and tell me exactly what to do. Do this, do that, and here are all the answers so I do not have to think for myself. I realized pretty quickly that is not what therapy is about. A good therapist is not there to make your decision for you. They are there to give you the skills and the tools to make a sound decision yourself.

That is exactly what I am trying to build in this community. It is frightening to me that a woman can be torn down for choosing, after a betrayal, that she wants to stay and try to work things out. So let me be clear about something important before we go any further.

I am giving you permission to be confident about any decision you make about your relationship. It is not my decision, or anyone else’s. It is what feels right and works for you.

---

A Necessary Line: Infidelity Is Not the Same as Abuse

I want to bring something important to light here. I am not talking about domestic violence in this post, and honestly, that is not a topic I touch on in my blog or my podcast at all. It is a serious, sensitive subject, and I keep it in the hands of licensed professionals who are trained to handle it properly. There are times in a relationship when it is genuinely not safe to stay, and that decision deserves resources far beyond anything I can offer here.

If you or someone you know is in an unsafe or abusive situation, please reach out to the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1 800 799 7233, or visit thehotline.org. They are available every day, all day, and they can help you think through next steps safely.

What I am talking about in this post is infidelity specifically. And infidelity, while absolutely traumatic, is something I believe can be workable and manageable when both partners are genuinely willing to do the work.

---

Why I Am Not the Judgmental Type

One of the reasons I am able to speak on infidelity without the usual moral high ground so many people bring to this topic is because I have been on both sides of it. In my own relationship, I know what it feels like to be betrayed. I also know what it feels like to be the one who did the betraying. That perspective changes you. It strips away the easy judgment, because you understand firsthand how complicated, human, and layered this situation really is.

I go much deeper into what actually separates a relationship with real rebuilding potential from one that is simply repeating the same wound on a loop in When to Leave vs. Stay After Infidelity, where I break down the honest signals that tell you whether rebuilding is even possible.

---

Staying Is Not Weakness. Leaving Is Not Failure.

So much of the outside pressure women feel after infidelity comes from a false idea that one choice is brave and the other is pathetic. That is simply not true. Choosing to stay and rebuild, when it is a genuine choice made with clarity, takes real strength. It means looking at something broken and believing it can become something honest. Choosing to leave, when it comes from clarity instead of fear, is not giving up either. It can be one of the most self honoring decisions a person ever makes.

There is actually a meaningful difference between walking away and giving up, and I unpacked that distinction fully in Clarity in Relationships: Walking Away vs Giving Up. Giving up tends to happen reactively, in a moment of exhaustion. Walking away tends to happen with reflection, even when the clarity arrives fast. Neither one makes you stupid, and neither one makes you a hero. They are just two different roads, and only you get to decide which one is yours.

---

Other People Do Not Live Inside Your Relationship

Here is something I feel strongly about. Whatever you decide, stay or go, the people around you offering their opinions do not live in your home. They were not there for the conversation that happened behind closed doors. They do not carry your specific history, your specific love, or your specific exhaustion. Their opinion is filtered through their own wounds and their own choices, not yours.

I go deep into this exact idea, including how many chances is actually enough and why the length of a relationship should inform your decision without ever being the only reason you stay, in Deciding to Stay: Filtering Out Others’ Opinions. A second chance is a privilege, not a right, and whether someone deserves it comes down to their behavior over time, not their words in the moment.

---

The Research Actually Backs This Up

If you are worried that staying and rebuilding after infidelity makes you naive, the numbers say otherwise. Multiple studies on infidelity recovery have found that somewhere between sixty and seventy five percent of couples stay together after an affair is discovered, and a meaningful share of those couples go on to report a relationship that is just as strong, or stronger, than it was before. Rebuilding is not some rare exception. It happens all the time, especially when both people are willing to put in real, sustained effort.

That does not mean staying is automatically the right call for everyone, and it does not mean rebuilding is easy. It just means the idea that infidelity is an automatic, non negotiable dealbreaker for every single person is not actually supported by how most couples experience it. Your relationship gets to be its own case study, not a statistic someone else decided for you.

---

Think of Therapy as a Tune Up, Not a Punishment

I want to say this directly, because I think it is one of the most important things in this entire post. Whatever route you choose, staying or going, therapy needs to be part of the equation somewhere. And I do not mean that as a negative.

Think about it this way. Even licensed professionals, the very people who help others heal, have to keep up their own certifications. They have to continue learning, continue training, continue proving they can still do the work well. Nobody is exempt from needing a tune up now and then, no matter how skilled or experienced they are. Your relationship deserves that same grace. Going to therapy does not mean something is fundamentally wrong with you or with your partner. It means you are willing to keep learning how to do this well, together.

You cannot walk around feeling like you are above everyone else, like you do not need to change or grow, because that is simply not how the world works. When you find a good therapist, someone who fits you and your partner specifically, that is when you will really understand what I mean. I talk more about how to find that right fit in Choosing the Right Support: Therapist, Counselor, or Coach, and if you are trying to hold onto yourself while you work through any of this, The Importance of Self Preservation in Relationships is worth reading too.

---

If You Are Trying to Understand Why It Happened at All

Part of moving forward, whether you stay or go, is understanding what led to the betrayal in the first place. Not to excuse it, but to make an informed decision instead of an emotional one made purely out of fear or shame. I explored that side of things in Why Do People Cheat Instead of Walking Away?, which looks honestly at what leads someone to that choice in the first place.

---

Key Takeaways

• Neither staying nor leaving after infidelity makes you stupid. Both decisions deserve respect when they come from clarity instead of fear or outside pressure.
• Infidelity is not the same as domestic violence. If you are in an unsafe situation, please contact the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1 800 799 7233 or visit thehotline.org.
• Research shows sixty to seventy five percent of couples stay together after infidelity, and many go on to build something stronger than before.
• Other people’s opinions about your relationship do not belong in your decision. They do not live inside it, and they never will.
• Therapy is not a punishment or an admission of failure. Think of it as a tune up, something every relationship deserves, regardless of how strong it already is.
• You are allowed to be confident in your own choice. It was never anyone else’s decision to make for you.

---

You Get to Decide

If there is one thing I want you to walk away with, it is this. Whatever route you decide, whether you stay and rebuild or whether you walk away, I am giving you permission to know that it is okay. Regardless of what the outside world might try to make you feel. But it is important to understand that both you and your partner have to be genuinely willing to do the work required to get through this, whichever direction you choose.

You are not required to explain yourself to anyone outside of that relationship. You are not required to perform strength for an audience that will never fully understand your specific history. Your decision belongs to you, and it always will.

---

Listen to More on Sherley’s Show

This post continues a conversation you can hear more of across Sherley’s Show. There are three ways to keep listening:

• Real Talk Series, where Kalief and I sit down together and talk honestly about the realities of a nearly thirty year relationship, including the parts most couples keep behind closed doors.
• Conversations, where Sherley and Kira go deep on infidelity, heartbreak, and what it actually takes to rebuild after crisis.
• Interviews, where guest experts and everyday women share their own perspective on love, betrayal, and healing.

You can find all three formats on the Sherley’s Show podcast page, and if you want more stories on strength, boundaries, and rebuilding a sense of self, browse the Empowerment category for more. If this gave you the permission you needed today, share it with a woman who needs to hear it too.

We are rooting for you. We always are.

---

---

Sherley’s Show is learning and growing every single day. We aim to uplift all marginalized voices both on this podcast and in real life. Please note that we are always striving to change the problematic language that society has internalized in us. Thank you for your patience as we aim to strip certain phrases from our vocabulary.

---

Would you like to be a guest

Are you interested in getting your opinion out about a particular topic but don’t know how to do so?  If so, here is an opportunity to do so to share your point of view, PLUS get your message and voice out there.  It is always a great way to know about different perspectives and enrich ourselves through knowledge sharing.

Be a Guest

---

Submit your relationship question.

Sherley’s Show provides an atmosphere where every woman is comfortable growing into their best self. Sherley’s Show is a no judgment podcast where we discuss how to rise strong out of all types of obstacles that come with relationships. Through personal life experiences and discussions ranging from infidelity, trust, forgiveness, sex, heartbreak, self love, therapy and more, we offer words of empowerment as you strive to build and maintain all of the relationships in your life. You may be going through something that is unique and difficult. Sharing your story gives others comfort and could also be helping someone else. Let them know they are not alone. Everyone has a story, do not let fear hold you back.

Listener Stories, & Questions

---

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links, I will get a commission if you decide to make a purchase through any of my links, at no cost to you. Please read my disclosure for more info.